These I believe are just good enough

Defensively, melee is the most vulnerable. In addition to RuneScape Gold taking the brunt of splash injuries from multi-target attackers like Vorago and Nex, as well as being vulnerable to the likes ROTS spins or Araxxor's swipes Melee also has restricted maneuverability. Melee protects opponents who attack using melee or in a different way.

If you're fighting about the raw power of a weapon versus its practicality, the strength doesn’t outweigh any difficulties that melee poses. It's like choosing between an iron bar and a gun. You can make more damage by hitting the bar if you hit it with enough force. But the gun is superior.

The main benefit of melee is the low price. Items such as the Saradomin Godsword as well as the upgraded excalibur offer certain healing capabilities. You would need to switch to ancients to obtain this ability, and must use blood spells. This only applies to players who are moderate to low level. It isn't important how much you spend on auras, scrimshaws, and noxious weapons.

These I believe are just good enough. They cover the completeness of tasks in RuneScape, doing "all" the jobs across all areas of RuneScape. Certain are more unique than others. The subtitle "The Annihilator". Does that refer to post-quest content? or a name from the new slayer monster. If there is post-quest material, then it might make sense.

These are not meant to be accomplished in RuneScape. These are secondary objectives that will help you gain experience in skills that you've already learned to 99 in 2007 RS Items the Completionist Cape, or assist you in achieving it. There are other methods of training, and they should be reserved to the Trimmed Cape.